Skip to content

Border Blogs & News

Blogs and news from the borders of America.

Menu
  • Home
  • El Paso News
  • El Paso Herald Post
  • Fronterizo News
Menu

El Chuqueño Blog – CREEED: Are We Fixing the Wrong Problem? Part 5

Posted on November 16, 2026

Who Holds the Reformers Accountable?

by Tim Holt

In the first four parts of this series, I’ve questioned whether CREEED is addressing the underlying causes of El Paso’s educational challenges or simply treating the symptoms. In Part 1, I examined the influence of business leaders on educational reform and whether their approach adequately considers the expertise of educators and the effects of poverty. In Part 2, I explored how El Paso’s unique cultural, linguistic, and socioeconomic circumstances complicate the way we measure school performance. In Part 3, I asked why the business leaders working to improve our schools aren’t placing greater emphasis on improving the economic conditions of the families whose children attend them. And in Part 4, I questioned whether CREEED’s support for charter school expansion, combined with inadequate state funding, might actually be making life more difficult for the public schools it wants to improve.

Which brings me to the final question. CREEED advocates educational reform, promotes accountability, and measures the performance of our schools. But who measures CREEED’s performance? Who determines whether its reforms are actually working, whether they’re producing unintended consequences, and whether the millions of dollars being invested are improving education for El Paso children as a whole? In other words, who holds the reformers accountable?

CREEED has gained considerable influence over the public conversation about education in El Paso since it was formed back in 2014. What happens when an organization with that kind of influence promotes policies that don’t produce the promised results?

The Political Elephant in the Classroom

CREEED isn’t simply a collection of concerned citizens meeting over coffee to discuss education. Its leadership includes some of El Paso’s most prominent businesspeople, investors, developers, and civic leaders. These are individuals with substantial economic influence, community connections, and relationships throughout the city’s political and business establishment. Los meros meros de El Paso.

Now imagine you’re a public school superintendent in El Paso.

CREEED is advocating educational reforms, supporting charter school expansion, and publishing statistics about how poorly schools are performing. You may disagree with some of its conclusions. You may even believe that certain initiatives are making your district’s financial situation more difficult. After all, CREEED openly promotes and subsidizes the very charter schools that pull students and funding away from your district. But how comfortable would you be publicly challenging an organization whose leadership includes some of the most influential people in town?

I’m not suggesting CREEED threatens superintendents or punishes districts that disagree with it. I have no evidence of that. But political influence doesn’t always require an explicit threat. Sometimes the perception of influence is enough to make people choose their words carefully. Has any school district turned down a CREEED-backed initiative when offered? I haven’t heard of any.

There’s also an apparent imbalance in accountability.

CREEED can advocate policies, fund initiatives, support charter school expansion, and criticize educational performance. Its leaders don’t have to operate thousands of classrooms every day, balance a public school district’s budget, comply with every state education requirement, or answer directly to voters for district operations. Public school leaders do.

If CREEED’s recommendations don’t produce the intended results, who is held responsible? The superintendent? The school board? The teachers? Or the people who promoted the reforms? CREEED can simply say, “Oh well, we tried. No harm, no foul.” Public school superintendents don’t have such a luxury. Bad scores? Many are summarily fired with a golden parachute and sent packing, and another El Paso school district starts from scratch with another carpetbagger with a slick PowerPoint presentation from Dallas or Houston, promising that THIS TIME they know “how to get things done.” Next.

That’s a question worth asking, particularly when the organization advocating change has considerable influence over the public conversation about education.

What About the Scholarships?

I can already hear someone pointing out that CREEED has helped students attend college through scholarships and other programs.

To its credit, CREEED recently announced Ascend, a three-year initiative involving four El Paso-area school districts and El Paso Community College. The program is designed to help students move successfully from high school into college, career training, and eventually employment. CREEED has committed to securing and providing more than $1 million to support the effort. That’s a substantial undertaking, and helping students navigate the often confusing transition between high school and college is certainly worthwhile.

But notice what Ascend is designed to accomplish: It prepares today’s students to become tomorrow’s workers. That’s important, but it doesn’t necessarily improve the economic circumstances of the families raising those students today. A student might eventually graduate with an excellent technical credential and obtain a good job, but that doesn’t help his parents pay this month’s rent or give them more time to help him with his homework. (You would be hard-pressed to find a high school teacher in our area who didn’t know of a student who missed school because he or she “had to help my family at work.”)

And there’s another question worth asking. Are we preparing students for jobs that will provide a decent standard of living, or simply preparing them to fill positions that employers need filled? Those aren’t necessarily the same thing. We should be interested in knowing whether Ascend will eventually measure graduates’ wages, benefits, and long-term economic mobility alongside their educational credentials. I would also ask if these jobs are available in El Paso, or will the students have to move away to be employed?

None of this is an argument against Ascend. Quite the opposite. It’s an example of the kind of cooperation between schools, colleges, and the business community that El Paso needs. But it also illustrates the distinction I’ve been making throughout these articles. Preparing children for a better economic future is not the same as improving the economic circumstances in which those children are growing up. Handing kids scholarships while they are going out the K–12 door does little to help them and their families while they were inside the K–12 environment.

I reviewed CREEED’s Ascend Insights Report and its 96-page Landscape Analysis. Both documents provide considerable information about the program’s goals, financial incentives, and measurements of success. But I couldn’t find a clear explanation of which students qualify to participate or how they are selected. Is Ascend available to every student in the four participating districts? What about the C student who isn’t college-ready? What about students learning English, students with disabilities, or students struggling academically? Are these the children Ascend intends to help, or will its resources concentrate on students already positioned to earn the credentials that generate additional state funding? I’m not suggesting that Ascend excludes anyone. I’m asking who gets helped, who decides, and how we’ll know whether the program is reaching the students who need it most. In my experience, there are a hell of a lot more “C” students than “A” students. Are we targeting them?

What about the third grader struggling with reading while her parents work two jobs? What about the middle school student whose family moves repeatedly because the rent keeps increasing? What about the high school student working evenings to help pay household expenses? Would those students benefit more from another educational initiative, or from improvements in their families’ economic circumstances?

CREEED has also supported workforce development efforts, and those deserve recognition. Connecting students with careers and employers is important. But preparing today’s students for tomorrow’s economy is not the same as improving today’s economy for the families raising those students. If a CREEED program got a student certified in, say, welding, and that student moved to Odessa to work in the oil fields, how exactly does that benefit El Paso?

Imagine if CREEED challenged its member businesses and other major employers to improve wages, expand family-friendly benefits, support affordable childcare, and create advancement opportunities for working parents and not just students. Imagine if it measured improvements in household economic security with the same enthusiasm it brings to measuring STAAR scores. Imagine an annual report documenting not only how many students met grade-level standards but also how many working families had experienced meaningful economic improvement.

Wouldn’t that be an interesting approach to educational excellence?

Who Is Held Accountable?

Now, I want to be clear about something. None of this excuses ineffective schools, poor instruction, or low expectations for students. Schools absolutely have a responsibility to educate children, regardless of their circumstances. Good teachers and good schools make a difference, particularly for children facing economic disadvantages. Likewise, poor teachers and poor instruction can have lifelong negative impacts.

But acknowledging that responsibility doesn’t mean pretending schools can solve every problem created by economic inequality, particularly when some of those problems are influenced by the very business leaders running CREEED. Don’t tell me that the single mother of two, working for minimum wage, is good for El Paso’s economic growth. For decades, we’ve asked public education to compensate for circumstances largely beyond its control. Poverty, hunger, housing instability, inadequate healthcare, and family economic insecurity all show up in classrooms every morning.

Then we judge schools by the academic performance of the children carrying those family burdens. And when the numbers aren’t good enough, along comes the elite class demanding educational reform and throwing money at it. Meanwhile, the economic conditions created and maintained by the elite class contribute to those challenges and often receive far less scrutiny.

As stated, CREEED has assembled some of El Paso’s most influential business leaders to improve educational outcomes. That’s an extraordinary collection of economic experience, resources, and influence. But perhaps that expertise could be directed more deliberately toward improving the economic circumstances of the families whose children attend our schools. (Minimum wage remains $7.25 an hour, while just up the road in Las Cruces, it is $13.01. Last time I checked, Las Cruces has not gone out of business because of excessive wages. If they can do it, then surely CREEED can advocate for El Paso to do the same. $18 an hour, anyone?)

Perhaps before promoting additional structural changes to public education, the organization should examine the consequences of the reforms it has already supported.

If charter school expansion has improved educational outcomes across the region, show us the meaningful evidence beyond a test score. If it has created financial difficulties for traditional districts, acknowledge those consequences. If socioeconomic conditions influence student performance, account for them when comparing schools. And if students are learning English while mastering academic subjects, recognize that additional challenge rather than treating every test score as a simple measure of school quality.

And if business leaders expect teachers and superintendents to be accountable for educational results, shouldn’t those same leaders accept some responsibility for the economic conditions that help shape those results?

After 38 years in education, I’ve come to believe that you cannot separate what happens in the home from what happens in the classroom. CREEED wants to improve El Paso’s economy by improving its schools. Maybe it’s time to consider improving El Paso’s schools by improving its economy first. The second will follow naturally.

And while we’re at it, perhaps we as a community should make sure our efforts to fix public education aren’t creating additional problems for the schools we say we are trying to improve.

Sources – CREEED: Are We Fixing the Wrong Problem?

1. CREEED – Our Story: https://www.creeed.org/who-we-are/our-story/
2. CREEED – Team and Board of Directors: https://www.creeed.org/who-we-are/team-board/
3. CREEED – Press Releases and Educational Initiatives: https://www.creeed.org/category/press-release/
4. CREEED – IDEA and Harmony Charter School Expansion: https://www.creeed.org/who-we-are/our-story/
5. CREEED – Ascend Program Announcement (2026): https://www.creeed.org/2026/10/01/creeed-and-partners-launch-ascend-program-to-strengthen-el-paso-students-paths-from-high-school-to-careers/
6. CREEED – Ensuring More El Paso Students Are Prepared for Skilled Careers (2026): https://www.creeed.org/2026/09/25/ensuring-more-el-paso-students-are-prepared-to-meet-the-growing-needs-for-skilled-workers/
7. Ascend Insights Report (2026): CREEED Report Page
8. Ascend Landscape Analysis (2026): CREEED Report Page
9. Johns Hopkins University – The Coleman Report at 50: https://hub.jhu.edu/magazine/2016/winter/coleman-report-public-education/
10. U.S. Census Bureau – El Paso QuickFacts: https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/elpasocitytexas
11. MIT – Living Wage Calculator, El Paso County: https://livingwage.mit.edu/counties/48141
12. Indeed – McDonald’s Crew Member Wages, El Paso: https://www.indeed.com/cmp/McDonald’s/salaries/Crew-Member/El-Paso-TX
13. City of Las Cruces – Minimum Wage Notice (2026–2027): https://lascruces.gov/minimum-wage-notice-for-2027/
14. Texas Education Agency – Charter School Finance: https://teadev.tea.texas.gov/finance-and-grants/state-funding/charter-school-funding/charter-school-finance
15. Texas Education Agency – Summary of Finances: https://teadev.tea.texas.gov/finance-and-grants/state-funding/foundation-school-program/summary-of-finances
16. Texas Education Agency – House Bill 2 Funding Changes (2025): https://tea.texas.gov/taa-letters/house-bill-2-hb-2-implementation-foundation-school-program-fsp-funding-formula-changes
17. Office of the Texas Governor – Public Education Funding, HB 2 (2025): https://gov.texas.gov/news/post/governor-abbott-signs-record-public-education-funding-teacher-pay-raise-into-law
18. IDEA Public Schools – Understanding Charter Schools: https://ideapublicschools.org/support-idea/learn-about-charter-schools/
19. IDEA Public Schools – Executive Leadership: https://ideapublicschools.org/our-story/leadership/
20. IDEA Public Schools – El Paso Regional Leadership: https://ideapublicschools.org/regions/el-paso/
21. IDEA Public Schools – Regional Boards and Advisory Councils: https://ideapublicschools.org/our-story/regional-board-of-directors/

 Read: Read More 

Recent Posts

  • Tech Crunch – OpenAI will embed Apollo researchers to investigate AI subversion
  • Tech Crunch – Instagram now lets creators add Amazon affiliate links in reels and feed posts
  • Tech Crunch – OpenAI releases a new image classifier and ChatGPT warnings to combat CSAM
  • Border Report – Brownsville man who hit ICE officers with his truck pleads not guilty to federal assault charges
  • El Chuqueño Blog – CREEED: Are We Fixing the Wrong Problem? Part 5

El Paso News

El Paso News delivers independent news and analysis about politics and public policy in El Paso, Texas. Go to El Paso News

Politico Campaigns

Are you a candidate running for office? Politico Campaigns is the go-to for all your campaign branding and technology needs.

Go to Politico Campaigns

Custom Digital Art

My name is Martín Paredes and I create custom, Latino-centric digital art. If you need custom artwork for your marketing, I'm the person to call. Check out my portfolio

©2026 Border Blogs & News | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme